jump to navigation

Stopping a Civil War – A Civil War is Brewing December 18, 2007

Posted by John in Technology.
trackback

Why I like Dave Winer – Timely leadership in the face of controversy.  Dave Winer is not my friend.  🙂 I’ve met Dave many times and have come to know his views and his “friends”.   He’s ten years older than I am and we disagree on many things (like the Amazon DB post) and agree on many others (like fair use).  I’ve notice one thing that is predictable about Dave.  He likes to make things happen and he says what is need to be said.  He’s a catalyst and an architect for getting things done.  He’s also has radical views in a good way.

Today he writes a great post on this fair use flare up.    This is what I like about Dave.  He gets involved and demonstrates leadership when it’s needed.  He rarely profits from it (at least directly).   He understands the pressure points in the emerging tech sector and mobilizes people around it – unconferences are a great example of it. 

Everyone is complaining about Lane Hartwell’s decision to ‘stop the music’ on the Richter Scales video – I think that it was a bad move.   It has caused alot of bad feeling in a time where we need to lighten up and celebrate life and Feed the World.

I support Dave’s flash conference and I think all creative people need to get behind this.  Creative Commons wasn’t meant to limit creativity but extend it. 

Dave cuts to the chase and points out the core issue:  Dave says “It’s a real mess we’re in. Bloggers are supposed to be radicals when it comes to fair use and copyright, but that generalization doesn’t work with many creative people. Hartwell’s position in some ways is like the RIAA or MPAA, who bloggers often dismiss as clueless. How can we have it both ways? How can some defend her position yet not defend the entertainment industry?” 

This is leadership in action.  This fair use issue isn’t going away and the industry needs to address it now sooner than later.   

Comments»

1. Michael Richie - December 18, 2007

Great post. I haven’t seen this analysis on it but I like your analogy. It’s a civil war. Look at the writers strike. Evidence is all around. This is a big problem and it is causing major polarization between what should be aligning forces. Thanks for pointing to Dave. I don’t follow him but I agree with his views. Radical is good in this case.

Keep the posts coming.

2. Andrew Hyde » Blog Archive » Wow - December 19, 2007

[…] will say just a bit on the ‘civil war‘ with the fair use issue. I would like to comment on what I can add value in. There is no way […]

3. Dave - December 19, 2007

great post.
Civil war it is

4. Creative Commons is Broken - Parsing Creative Commons « Furrier.org - December 20, 2007

[…] Stopping a Civil War – A Civil War is Brewing « Furrier.org – December 18, […]

5. Nalts Fans the Flames of Online Civil War - December 25, 2007

[…] from those who are a bit more aware of how fair use works on the Internet. As John Furrier noted, a civil war is brewing in the blogosphere, and as Nalts says, at the moment it’s over air.My personal feeling is that the solution lies […]

6. Nalts Fans the Flames of Online Civil War — Parking Domains - December 31, 2007

[…] from those who are a bit more aware of how fair use works on the Internet. As John Furrier noted, a civil war is brewing in the blogosphere, and as Nalts says, at the moment it’s over air.My personal feeling is that the solution lies […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: